Saturday, December 22, 2007

In A Lonely Place by Dorothy B. Hughes

In A Lonely Place by Dorothy B. Hughes
Femmes Fatales, 1947
Suspense/Thriller; 250 pgs

Completed: 12/21/2007
Rating: * (Good +)

First Sentence: It was good standing there on the promontory overlooking the evening sea, the fog lifting itself like gauzy veils to touch his face.

Reason for Reading: I am sure this book was recommended by one of the author’s I heard speak at the Los Angeles Times Festival of Books in 2006, however, I forgot to write it down. I do know that I walked away from the festival that April with a copy of the book, both my husband and I interested in reading it.

This is my 11th selection for the TBR Challenge, my 1940’selection for the Reading Through the Decades Challenge and my 4th selection for the Unread Authors Challenge.

Comments: In A Lonely Place is purported as author Dorothy B. Hughes best novel, a hardboiled noir set in postwar Los Angeles. Dix Steele is cocky and sure of himself as the novel begins. Although written in third person, the author never strays from the main character’s point of view as the world and the events in the novel filter solely through his viewpoint. He makes for an interesting protagonist, although never a likeable one. It is obvious from the first page he does not think much of women. Instead, sharp-eyed psychologist Sylvia Nicolai and the fiery Laurel Gray, who knows exactly what she wants and goes after it without hesitation, are the two characters who stand out and demand respect from readers. Dix falls hard for the beautiful Laurel Gray, a woman unlike any other he has come across before. She may just be his match and what follows is not at all what Dix could have anticipated.

Sylvia’s husband is none other than Detective Nicolai, Dix’s best friend. His latest case is tracking down a killer known as the Strangler who has left a string of female victims in his wake. Dix takes particular interest in the investigation.

For those who do not care for reading violent scenes, the novel is not at all graphic and instead is more psychological in its approach. Dorothy B. Hughes capably builds suspense and wonder throughout her novel. I cannot say that this particular novel stands out above some of the other serial killer novels of its kind I have read. Although cold and calculated, the killer was never really frightening as a character. Perhaps that in part was because the author did paint the killer as a somewhat sympathetic person. The murderer was smart, no doubt, but overconfidence and rationalization never failed to make the killer seem less so.

In A Lonely Place was an entertaining novel and also made for interesting reading as a period piece. Dorothy B. Hughes’ novel stepped outside of the lines during its day, offering up strong willed and intelligent women and challenging the societal notion that women shared the blame in their victimization. Dorothy B. Hughes certainly earned the high praise her book has received.

Favorite Part: Sylvia’s character most intrigued me, and I almost wish the author could have shone a light on her a little more. However, the novel would not have been quite so effective otherwise.

Miscellaneous: In A Lonely Place may be better known for the 1950 movie version starring Humphrey Bogart as Dix Steele. As often happens, movies are not exact reflections of the books they are based on, and, in this case, the movie definitely takes the story in a different direction than the novel takes the reader.


  1. Sounds like an interesting book, LF.

    Speaking of movies, I've been watching a lot of AMC and TCM lately. I've managed to catch some of those 'film noire' kinda movies and I'm constantly amazed by how they handled the lighting and staging. So much better than now, if you ask me.

    This book made me think of that sort of movie.


  2. Don't you just love older books? Sometimes the dialogue is hard to understand but I generally love them anyways!

  3. Good to hear about this! I have an omnibus of three books by Hughes (including this one) but had never heard of her before. Now I know what to expect! Sounds good.

  4. Oh! I've seen the movie, I think. With Humphrey Bogart and Gloria Grahame. I'll have to check the book out. It sounded so familiar, but I'm sure the book was different. They almost always are.

    Out of idle curiousity, out of one TBR book off the shelves, how many get added? I was noticing a dismaying trend in my library.

  5. Just wanted to wish you a very Merry Christmas!

  6. That sounds like a fun book. I love the covers of those older noir novels.

    Merry Christmas, Wendy!

  7. Jen - I do enjoy older books. My husband especially enjoys the reading older noir fiction, which encourages me to read more of it.

    Nicola - You'll have to let me know what you think of the book when you read it, as well as the other two books in the omnibus.

    Carrie K - Yes, that's the one. I'd like to see the movie just to compare--and because I like old movies. :-)

    I try not to keep count of how many books come in for every one that goes out. Terrible, I know, but I'd probably have a heart attack. Or give my husband one. Let's just say that I rarely walk out of a bookstore with just one or two books.

    Lynne - Thanks so much! I hope you have a nice one too.

    Nancy - It is a fun one. I like the covers on the older ones too. :-) Have a happy Christmas also!


Thank you for taking the time to visit Musings of a Bookish Kitty. Don't be shy! I would love to hear from you. Due to a recent increase in spam, I will be moderating all comments for the foreseeable future. Please be patient with me as it may take a few hours before I am able to approve your comment.