Monday, December 03, 2007

The Somnambulist by Jonathan Barnes

The Somnambulist by Jonathan Barnes
William Morrow, 2008 (ARE)
Fiction; 353 pgs

Completed: 11/30/2007
Rating: * (Good)

First Two Sentences: Be warned. This book has no literary merit whatsoever.

Reason for Reading: This was a Harper Collins selection I was chosen to review through the publisher’s First Look Program. The description of the book intrigued me, and so I thought I would give it a try.

From the Publisher: The Somnambulist follows the extraordinary tale of Edward Moon, stage magician and detective, and his silent sidekick the somnambulist. A bizarre series of murders unsettles turn-of-the-century London, but as Moon begins to investigate, he realizes it is only the beginning: nourished by blood and poetry, an eerie uprising grows among the very roots of the city.

Comments: The first paragraph of the novel instantly had my attention. I knew I was in for something different. It is difficult to describe a book like this. It isn’t quite what one might expect from the description offered by the publisher. It certainly is a bit of a detective story, but it also flows over into the macabre and fantastic.

Edward Moon, stage magician and detective, is bored of doing magic tricks and reading minds. He has not faced a memorable foe in a very long time, and so even while he pretends to be quite reluctant, he agrees to help the police solve a rather unusual and gruesome murder. What unfolds is a dark and magical tale, one fraught with horrors and conspiracy galore.

The characters lean toward bizarre and unbelievable, just as the narrator warns readers at the beginning of the book. Of course, this is what makes them all the more interesting. There is the albino, Skimpole, who nobody seem to like; the ugly man, Thomas Cribb, who is knows much more than he is able to say; the giant, milk guzzling Somnambulist who does not speak; Miss Grossmith, the ever faithful housekeeper; Barabbas the Fiend, who is quite crazed while still brilliant; Mrs. Puggsley, the brothel madam, who serves a clientele with rather special tastes; and Edward Moon, who is past his prime but is not quite ready to let the world forget him.

The narrator’s voice throughout the book is entertaining to say the least. The narrator, however unreliable, was witty and amusing, even with his asides that sometimes had me rolling my eyes. “I expect by now that your disbelief is not so much suspended as dangling from the highest plateau of credulity.” [p334] And with that quote, I found myself nodding in complete agreement.

Although I take no issue with the choice in narrator and actually think it makes for a more interesting twist to the story, my opinion of the narrator was not so high after learning his true identity. The mystery gone and the motive clear, the narrator seemed rather ordinary. Perhaps that was exactly what the author intended.

The Somnambulist is quirky, dark and utterly entertaining. Jonathan Barnes has written a novel that at times will confound the reader and yet everything comes together in the end in unexpected ways. This was one book in which I never guessed what might happen next.

Favorite Part: Thomas Cribb. I was fascinated by his story and quite intrigued by his life. To say exactly what it was about him that most attracted me to the character would be to give too much away, unfortunately.

Least Favorite Part: I wish I knew more about the poet Samuel Taylor Coleridge. Although knowing nothing about him did not hurt my enjoyment or understanding of events in the book, I do think that knowing more about his life, including his vision of Pantisocracy, might have enhanced my reading experience.


  1. Don't you just love a book that warns you like that?

    This one sounds intriguing...


  2. Oh man. This book sounds like so much fun. I will def have to add it to TBR stacks.

    Great review!

  3. I'm very tempted now... I think I will stay away from your bloggie because if I don't I'll keep on buying books. Just kidding! LOL.

    Great review, Wendy! :D

  4. Sounds like an interesting book! I'll have to look for it at the library.


  5. You make that one sound really good, must see if the library has got it. I like the warning, sounds like my kind of book!

  6. I can't resist books set in turn of the century! This one is going on my list :)

  7. Turn of the century, a magician/detective, a sidekick/sonambulist, and cast of bizarre characters/suspects. I'm interested in this one!

  8. I'll have to brush up on my STC bio. Looks like a good read!

  9. CJ - I loved the entire opening paragraph. I almost gave it all to you. :-) My husband was less impressed when I made him read it. Haha Anyhow, that kind of opening is always sure to pull me in.

    Nikki - It is a lot of fun. Very weird. At least for me. :-)

    Alice - Haha Please don't stay away! I'll try to read some bad books to keep people from adding to their TBR collections and wish lists. On second thought, I'd rather not try that.;-)

    Amy - I think it'll be out in February in the U.S. It's been out for awhile in the U.K.

    GeraniumCat - It's a very catchy opening, isn't it? I hope you will like it when you do read it.

    Iliana - It is an interesting time period. I really like how my favorite character, Thomas Cribb, puts it all into perspective.

    Jenclair - It does sound intriguing doesn't it? I'm embarrassed to admit it, but I hadn't even known what a somnambulist was until I read the book. It's one of my new favorite words.

    Carrie - I think brushing up on STC is a great idea. Not necessary, but as I mentioned above, it may enhance your experience with the book. I wish I had known then what I know now. :-)

    Andi - As you know, I usually only post the first sentence, but I couldn't resist adding in the second. :-)

  10. I'm glad you kept reading after the first two sentences--great review, sounds interesting--have you read "The Devil in the White City?"

  11. Once again you hooked me with an interesting title! It sounds intriguing and....again...I wish to read your recommendation.

    Thanks! (I think.)

  12. Sage - No, I haven't yet, but I have it somewhere around here to eventually try. I've heard great things about The Devil in the White City.

    Carrie - It was an interesting book. Weird, but interesting. :-)


Thank you for taking the time to visit Musings of a Bookish Kitty. Don't be shy! I would love to hear from you. Due to a recent increase in spam, I will be moderating all comments for the foreseeable future. Please be patient with me as it may take a few hours before I am able to approve your comment.