Hanover Square Place, 2019
Fiction (Historical); 352 pgs
Fiction (Historical); 352 pgs
Singapore, 1942. As Japanese troops sweep down Malaysia and into Singapore, a village is ransacked, leaving only two survivors and one tiny child.
In a neighboring village, seventeen-year-old Wang Di is strapped into the back of a troop carrier and shipped off to a Japanese military brothel where she is forced into sexual slavery as a “comfort woman.” After sixty years of silence, what she saw and experienced still haunts her.
In the year 2000, twelve-year-old Kevin is sitting beside his ailing grandmother when he overhears a mumbled confession. He sets out to discover the truth, wherever it might lead, setting in motion a chain of events he never could have foreseen.
Weaving together two time lines and two very big secrets, this stunning debut opens a window on a little-known period of history, revealing the strength and bravery shown by numerous women in the face of terrible cruelty. Drawing in part on her family’s experiences, Jing-Jing Lee has crafted a profoundly moving, unforgettable novel about human resilience, the bonds of family and the courage it takes to confront the past.
I am full of feelings right now, having just finished Jing-Jing Lee's How We Disappeared. I knew the moment I first read a description of this book, I had to read it.
The chapters alternate between the stories of twelve-year-old Kevin, as he uncovers his grandmother's long held secret, and Wang Di as she reflects and comes to terms with her past.
"'Listen. Do what helps you. If hoping helps you survive from day to day, then keep hoping that they're going to release you. The truth is, I've never seen them let anyone go. But if it helps you.'" [Excerpt from How We Disappeared]
Wang Di was the oldest child and only daughter of her family. When the Japanese marched into Singapore, they wielded their power cruelly and viciously, gunning down entire villages and kidnapping young girls and women, among other reprehensible actions. At sixteen, Wang Di was forced to be a sex slave for Japanese soldiers. She was one of many, trapped in a life she never asked for. Their living conditions were abysmal and their future uncertain. Despite everything, the shame she felt and the pain she endured, Wang Di found the strength to survive--to persevere.
The reception the "comfort women" received upon their return home after the war ended was anything but welcoming. While Wang Di was welcomed back into her parents' home, she was still an outcast. Other women were not so fortunate, being turned out and shunned. Shame and grief were carried on all sides. The families of these unfortunate women did not understand or want to acknowledge what the girls had suffered through. And the victims themselves felt ashamed and ruined, afraid to discuss what had happened to them. It just wasn't talked about--and still isn't in many circles. Just think of the stigma surrounding rape victims today.
Now a widow, Wang Di has many regrets, one of which is not listening to her husband's stories about his time during the war and in not sharing her own story with him while he was alive. For years she refused to listen or talk about the war, not wanting to relive it, at least not out loud. She suffered in silence.
I realized then, what she meant to say, so for the rest of the time I was in her flat, I made sure not to look away from her so that she would know she didn't have anything to be ashamed about. [Excerpt from How We Disappeared]
Sometimes it was easy to forget Kevin is only twelve-years-old given how tenacious and thoughtful he could be. He loved his grandmother dearly and when she confesses to him a rather big secret on her deathbed, he knows he cannot just let it go. On his own, he sets out to discover the truth, hoping it will bring some solace to his grieving father.
I came to love both Kevin and Wang Di's through their stories. Often in dual narratives, one side is stronger than the other, but Jing-Jing Lee has found the perfect balance between the voices of her characters. Through Wang Di and Kevin, the reader is introduced to other significant characters, including Wang Di's husband and Kevin's parents. Also the amazingly strong women Wang Di was with during her captivity. I was sad to see the novel come to an end, wanting to spend more time with the characters, and yet also satisfied that their stories had come to a conclusion--at least as far as the author meant to take us.
I have read a lot of novels set during World War II, but so few that focus on the Pacific (my own fault, and I am trying to remedy that). How We Disappeared is a poignant novel, which focuses on a part of history that has too often been buried that we all need to remember. And not just for the horrors produced so we do not repeat them--although that is important--but also to remember the victims and survivors, of their strength and perseverance, and to give them a voice so they are no longer kept silent.
How We Disappeared is a beautiful and heart-wrenching novel that had me in tears more than once--in sadness and anger, but also in hope and joy; devastating and yet filled with heart. This is my absolute favorite book that I have read so far this year.
Amazon | Books-A-Million | Bar
nes & Noble
For more information about the author and her work, visit her website. You can also find her on Twitter.
I hope you will check out what others had to say about Beautiful Bad on the TLC Book Tours route!
Many thanks to the TLC Book Tours for the opportunity to be a part of this book tour. Review copy provided by publisher for an honest review.
© 2019, Musings of a Bookish Kitty. All Rights Reserved. If you're reading this on a site other than Musings of a Bookish Kitty or Wendy's feed, be aware that this post has been stolen and is used without permission.
I've definitely got to read this! The scars from Japanese Occupation still run deep for many older Singaporeans and it's something that we shouldn't forget (although we definitely shouldn't be holding grudges about it either - I'm sure there's a way we can honour the past without hating the present).ReplyDelete
Eustacia - I imagine the scars do still run deep. What a horrible time in history. The things human do to others . . . I think the best we can do is remember, learn from it, and grow in such a way to prevent things like this happening again. Unfortunately, it's still going on in parts of the world today--just different cultures, different aggressors and different victims.Delete
I don't think I've ever read a WWII book set in the Pacific and I'm wondering if there are many of them out there. I can tell you loved this one so I'm adding it to my wish list.ReplyDelete
Kathy - I have not come across very many. I really did love this one and highly recommend it.Delete
I've read a couple of books that focus (in retrospect) about the horrors of the Japanese Occupation of Singapore. What a recommendation that this is your favorite book of the year!ReplyDelete
Jenclair - It was very good.Delete
Your favorite book of the year is quite the recommendation! This does sound like a good one. Stories from this side of WWII need to be told, too.ReplyDelete
Lark - I think so too! I am so glad this book came my way.Delete
Despite the years, the horrors of the Japanese Occupation still lingers in all Singaporean's minds. It's always painful to be reminded of the war yet it is important and the history needs to be told. Without a doubt I'll have to add this to my wishlist.ReplyDelete
Melody - I can only imagine. It's not something someone who went through it would want to remember, but it's so important that it not be forgotten just the same--especially for the generations that came after. I hope you do read this one. I would love your take on it.Delete
I'm adding it to mine as well. As this generation of individuals is swiftly leaving this world (the ones that remember WWII), I'm glad that stories are being told regarding all aspects of the war.ReplyDelete
Kay - I hope you like it when you read it.Delete
Wow, Wendy, such high praise :) I had a feeling this was going to be a great read for you and your review is tugging at me to read it, though I doubt I'll get to it. I want to FEEL when I read and this sounds like a gem. I wonder if I can handle it though. I'm not sure I want to be plagued by the horrific parts :( and it immediately brought to mind two things: there was a lot of rape of Japanese women by American soldiers post war, too, when America was there :( It also made me think of a paragraph from a book I'm reading now (WHEN THE NIGHT SINGS) that describes an instance in a concentration camp where 2 Nazi soldiers take an infant from his mother, throw it under a train, the mother runs to it and they shoot them both. I couldn't get it out of my head for two days and thinking of it now is too much. Don't know how deep I want to get right now. So glad you enjoyed it this much!ReplyDelete
I just finished reading two books (1 and 2) that I was feeling strongly about too: THE WAR THAT SAVED MY LIFE and THE WAR I FINALLY WON. I was completely invested in the characters and their plight. It was also World War II in England.
Donna Marie - The incident you described in the book you are reading sounds so horrific. I can't even imagine. Humans are our own worst enemies. The atrocities and horrors we commit against each other . . .Delete
It sounds like your reading as of late has been emotional too.
What a beautiful review! Your review brought tears to my eyes! How devastating and traumatizing for these women to be shunned and have felt such shame on top of being raped by Japanese soldiers. I've. never read or seen any movies that have focused on the Pacific during WWII.ReplyDelete
Lindy@ A Bookish Escape
Lindy - Thank you. I was so moved by this book and these women's experiences.Delete
I really love stories of an older person having to share their story that they've maybe held in all of these years. I enjoy hearing other people's stories in general, but knowing when it's one that was hidden for so long feels profound to me. Thank you for being on this tour! Sara @ TLC Book ToursReplyDelete
Sara - I do too. There's something to be said for this type of storytelling.Delete