Atria Books, 2007
Fiction; 464 pgs
I remember the first time I read a book by Jodi Picoult. How moved I was by her ability to present several sides of a controversial topic that really made me think. Picoult is an author who likes to write about those hot button issues. She is able to take the darkest of subjects and make them approachable. I won't say she never shows a bias. She's only human. But I do think she (mostly) presents a fair and well rounded case for the subjects she takes on. I say this only having read five of Jodi Picoult's books.
The subject matter in her more recent books haven't interested me too much, but I've long been meaning to get to Nineteen Minutes. With all the school shootings that had been in the news, it was a topic on the minds of many. And it has only gained relevance with each new school shooting that's taken place.
Synopsis from the Publisher:
In Sterling, New Hampshire, 17-year-old high school student Peter Houghton has endured years of verbal and physical abuse at the hands of classmates. His best friend, Josie Cormier, succumbed to peer pressure and now hangs out with the popular crowd that often instigates the harassment. One final incident of bullying sends Peter over the edge and leads him to commit an act of violence that forever changes the lives of Sterling’s residents.
Even those who were not inside the school that morning find their lives in an upheaval, including Alex Cormier. The superior court judge assigned to the Houghton case, Alex—whose daughter, Josie, witnessed the events that unfolded—must decide whether or not to step down. She’s torn between presiding over the biggest case of her career and knowing that doing so will cause an even wider chasm in her relationship with her emotionally fragile daughter. Josie, meanwhile, claims she can’t remember what happened in the last fatal minutes of Peter’s rampage. Or can she? And Peter’s parents, Lacy and Lewis Houghton, ceaselessly examine the past to see what they might have said or done to compel their son to such extremes.
Nineteen Minutes is not meant to explain away all school shootings; it's just the fictional story about Peter, Josie, and their parents. It's about one school shooting, the impact it had on a community and those involved, and an attempt to understand why it happened.
In her usual style, Picoult tells the story from the perspective of multiple characters, allowing the reader to experience the book through the eyes of each of them. It's a difficult book to read on many levels. As a parent. As a human being. What Peter did was wrong no matter how you look at it. It would be easy to stop at that and look no further. Then again, it is human nature to try and understand why of how such horrible tragedies like this can happen. The answer, no matter how tragic in and of itself, doesn't make what happened right--it doesn't take the guilt away from the shooter, but it should get us to stop and think about our own behavior and responses as well as the community and institutions in which we live and work.
Peter isn't an easy character to like. I mean, look at what he did. I did feel bad for what he went through as a child; how he was bullied and picked on from such a young age and how little support and guidance he got from those around him who might have been able to help. I think Peter's defense attorney made some good points in that regard. Still, as awful as Peter was treated and as much as I could see the path set that he traveled on to get to where he was, it didn't excuse what he'd done.
Josie's own story paralleled Peter's in some respects. They both struggled in their own ways, Peter just more obviously. Josie was always pretending, trying hard to fit in and turning a blind eye, meanwhile losing herself in the process. It's sad really, given how close Josie and Peter once were. But it isn't hard to understand, unfortunately.
Before I had a child, I always tended to identify most with the children/teens. Now I seem to identify more with the parents. And so it came as no surprise that I took a particular interest in the sections involving the parents of Josie and Peter. I really felt bad for Peter's parents. How quickly the community turned against them and blamed them for their son's actions. That isn't to say they were perfect or couldn't have done anything differently--it just seemed unfair to treat them as guilty too, especially since, in their own way, they were victims in this too. But we do that, don't we? In our effort to understand the why of a tragedy we also seek to blame. And not just the perpetrator.
As for Alex, Josie's mother, the judge, she fought against giving the case up for quite a while. I was surprised she even considered keeping it, frankly, given her and her daughter's past with Peter and his family. I felt for her though, as she made efforts to get to know her daughter better, the shooting having shaken something loose in her, making her realize how distant the two of them had become.
I felt sad for Peter and Josie. I felt sad for the victims and their families and friends. At times I felt angry and frustrated. The shooting didn't have to happen. Peter didn't have to take it that far. If only someone had stepped in at an earlier point in Peter's life . . . Not that some didn't try in their own ways. It just wasn't enough. How can we really know though, until after the fact? It's easy to point fingers in the aftermath and say what should have been done differently. But by then it's too late. I guess we hope we learn from our mistakes so there won't be a next time. As I said, this was a difficult book to read.
There's more, of course. With Jodi Picoult there always is. And, yes, Picoult adds in her trademark twist--although I have to say it wasn't really surprising at all. The author had left pretty clear footprints in this instance. Even so, I have mixed feelings about the ending. And there were other things, small things, I took issue with, but nothing I can share without spoiling important points.
This is a book I could talk about for quite a while. It raises many salient points, including the no tolerance bullying policies at schools and how effective they really are, gun safety, and parental supervision/monitoring among others. It would make a great book club selection as many of Jodi Picoult's books would. This book opens the way for so much discussion about topics that are worth taking the time to explore.
You can learn more about Jodi Picoult and her books on the author's website.
Source: I bought a copy of this book for my own reading pleasure.
© 2013, Wendy Runyon of Musings of a Bookish Kitty. All Rights Reserved. If you're reading this on a site other than Musings of a Bookish Kitty or Wendy's feed, be aware that this post has been stolen and is used without permission.
I have had this book forever. Ok, maybe a year or so, so I should be reading this soon. It does sound good, so I might pick it up soon rather than later. Thanks for sharing your thoughts!ReplyDelete
Melinda - Haha! I have quite a few books on my shelves I can say the same about. :-)Delete
Also a fan of JP though I admit to finding her novels formulaic I have several of her books on my TBR pile.ReplyDelete
Tracy - I like Jodi Picoult in small doses for that very reason.Delete
It has been a while since I read Nineteen Minutes, but it was the last one I read, because I felt like I'd had enough of her trademark style. I felt exactly the same way as you after reading The Pact (I think before she became such a well-known author), though. I thought she really captured the turmoil the parents must go through when their teen children are involved )or responsible for) a tragedy. I read several others over the years, but with this one I guessed the ending, and figured I'd move on! Now I'm reading my first book by Elin Hilderbrand, and thinking she may be someone to recommend to Jodi Picoult fans?ReplyDelete
Laurie - I hear that a lot about Jodi Picoult. She definitely has a set story telling style. That's partly why I don't read her books back to back.Delete
I haven't read Elin Hilderbrand before, but I've heard good things about her books.
I read this a while ago (after the shootings at Tech) and liked it but also felt Picoult tried to make it seem that all shootings are caused by bullying and that's not the case. Still the book has value if it gets people thinking about bullying and mental health issues.ReplyDelete
Kathy - I didn't get the impression that Picoult was speaking about ALL school shootings, but rather offering one take on a possible scenario. Bullying is one of the major reasons given today for school violence and so I do think it makes a book like this relevant.Delete
I have yet to read Picoult, but I have one of her books on my TBR...Plain Truth. Have you read that one? Did you like it?ReplyDelete
Andi - I read Plain Truth years ago and really liked it. It isn't a fast paced novel, but I thought the author did a good job with the subject matter. I hope you like it if you do read it.Delete
This was my first experience with Picoult - I listened to it on audiobook - and was mesmerized. In fact, it's been long enough, I could probably listen to it again.ReplyDelete
Carrie - I bet it was good in audio form!Delete
I want to read Picoult but am yet to read of one that really sparks an interest (My Sister's Keeper sounded quite difficult, for instance). This one sounds like it could be it, even if biased (I'd keep that in mind). An important topic to explore.ReplyDelete
Charlie - Picoult's subject matter is always of a controversial nature in terms of making one really think. I really enjoyed My Sister's Keeper when I read it years ago.Delete
I do enjoy Picoult's novels, but I can only read them every once in awhile since I've grown tired of her usual formula. I think Nineteen Minutes was the first one I read. It really does get you to consider what the shooter's parents are going through and what his motives might have been. I did feel sorry for him, but like you say, that's no excuse.ReplyDelete
Anna - Yes, same here. I can only take her in small doses. I really liked that we got to explore how parents might be impacted by something like a school shooting.Delete
I've only read My Sister's Keeper and was really disappointed with the ending but I would like to give her another try. Not sure if this is the one I would choose next though.ReplyDelete
Iliana - I know a lot of people were disappointed with the ending in My Sister's Keeper. I balled my eyes out, but I found it fitting myself.Delete
I don't care for this author's writing in general, but this was a powerful read. We read it for book club so there was plenty to discuss and then some!ReplyDelete
Ti - This one definitely makes for a good book club pick!Delete
I have to read Jodi Picoult. I think I'd enjoy her work. This does sound like a book that makes for great discussion. I like getting the story from a few different characters points of view as well, so long as it's not confusing.ReplyDelete
Naida - Picoult's chapters are clearly marked in terms of who is thinking or saying what so I don't think you'd find the multiple narrators confusing. I hope you do enjoy her books if you decide to give them a try!Delete
I read Picoult sparingly. Can you believe the latest almost-shooting? If Picoult had written it as a book no one would have believed it!ReplyDelete
Stacy - She's not an author I have to read every book she's ever written, but I do like the books I've read by her.Delete
I've read this one and it stuck with me for quite awhile after I read it. The first book that I read by her (My Sister's Keeper) still is my favorite but this was a close second. It just made me think and you are right: it is very relevant after all of the school shootings that have happened. Great review!!ReplyDelete
Samantha - Thanks! This one has stayed with me for awhile too, Samantha. (And My Sister's Keeper is my favorite too.)Delete
I've never read any Piccoult, partly because I was concerned that she might try to take on too many issues and not be unbiased enough. Sounds like I would enjoy this one, though, and that she does a good job giving the reader a lot to think about from all sides.ReplyDelete
Lisa - I do think she does a fairly good job of presenting multiple sides to a situation fairly, even when she sneaks in a little bias.Delete